The National Soccer Coaches Association of America (NSCAA) named 43 girls to the 2015 NSCAA Fall High School All-American list on December 7. Of the 43 players chosen, 21 are repeat selections.
The All-Americans will be honored at the NSCAA All-America Luncheon on January 16 at the 2016 NSCAA Convention in Baltimore, Maryland.
2015 Fall High School All-Americans
*Repeat selection
| Pos | Name | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Toni Bizzarro | Sr. | Mason High School | Mason, Ohio |
| K | Lauren Gallagher* | Sr. | Pearl River High School | Peark River, N.Y. |
| K | Brooke Heinsohn | Sr. | The Rivers School | Norfolk, Mass. |
| K | Imani McDonald | Sr. | Long Beach Polytechnic High School | Long Beach, Calif. |
| K | Maddie Zuberer | Sr. | KIrtland High School | Kirtland, Ohio |
| D | Lexie Carrier* | Sr. | Indian Hill High School | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| D | Abigail Ross | Jr. | Long Beach Wilson High School | Long Beach, Calif. |
| D | Elizabeth Webber* | Sr. | The Rivers School | Natick, Mass. |
| M | Malia Berkely* | Sr. | Stephen T. Badin High School | Liberty Township, Ohio |
| M | Hannah Cade | Sr. | Lakeville North High School | Lakeville, Minn. |
| M | Mara Cosentino* | Sr. | Glastonbury High School | Glastonbury, Conn. |
| M | Nikki Cox* | Sr. | Granville High School | Newark, Ohio |
| M | Ashley Dobbins* | Sr. | Archbishop Hoban High School | Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio |
| M | Nia Dorsey | Sr. | Our Lady of Good Counsel | Elkridge, Md. |
| M | Emina Ekic* | Jr. | DuPont Manual High School | Louisville, Ky. |
| M | Emma Hasco* | Sr. | Upper St. Clair School District | Upper St Clair, Pa. |
| M | Alia Martin | Jr. | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | Carmel, Ind |
| M | Casey Richards* | Sr. | Northern Highlands Regional High School | Allendale, N.J. |
| M | Sphia Rossi | Jr. | Walsh Jesuit High School | Akron, Ohio |
| M | Hayley Soriano* | Sr. | Bridgewater-Raritan Regional High School | Bridgewater, N.J. |
| M | Abby Sotomayor* | Sr. | The Loomis Chaffee School | Colchester, Conn. |
| F | Amirah Ali* | Jr. | Eastern High School | Voorhees, N.J. |
| F | Bridgette Andrzejewski * | Sr. | McDonogh School | Lutherville, Md. |
| F | Jenna Bike* | Sr. | Saint Joseph High School | Trumbull, Conn. |
| F | Ryanne Brown | Jr. | Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| F | Gabi Brummett* | Jr. | The Derryfield School | Bow, N.H. |
| F | Jillian Colucci | Jr. | Earl .L Vandermuelen High School | Port Jefferson, N.Y. |
| F | Juliana Comer | Sr. | Winston Churchill High School | Potomac, Md. |
| F | Opal Curless | Sr. | Mount Desert Island High School | Mount Desert, Maine |
| F | Rachael Dorwart | So. | Cumberland Valley | Mechanicsburg, Pa. |
| F | Hannon Eberts* | Sr. | Somers High School | Katonah, N.Y. |
| F | Jade Gentile | Sr. | Baker HIgh School | Baldwinsville, N.Y. |
| F | Jordyn Greer | Sr. | St. Ursula Academy | Toledo, Ohio |
| F | Anna Gregg | Sr. | St. Francis Catholic High School | Sacramento, Calif. |
| F | Gabby Little* | Sr. | Houston High School | Collierville, Tenn. |
| F | Emma Loving* | Sr. | Central Bucks East High School | Doylestown, Pa. |
| F | Abby McKearin | Sr. | Proctor High School | Proctor, Vt. |
| F | Kia Rankin* | Sr. | McDonogh School | Bowie, Md. |
| F | Ally Reynolds | Sr. | Weymouth High School | Weymouth, Mass. |
| F | Julianne Ross | Jr. | Cumberland High School | Cumberland, R.I. |
| F | Abby Steiner | So. | Dublin Coffman High School | Dublin, Ohio |
| F | Jillian Vassallo* | Sr. | Bishop George Ahr High School | Edison, N.J. |
| F | Olivia Ware | Jr. | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, Calif. |